I know you've already decided in favor of #1 -- which I definitely think was a good decision -- but I just wanted to offer further support by saying that I think that although #1 isn't something you'll wear often, I think it's a pretty classic style and I think you might be surprised at the number of weddings, brunches, parties, etc. over the years that you might be able to wear it to. I have a few great fitting and gorgeous dresses that sort of remind of that one and I've worn them for like seven years because there's just always some occasion that comes up that they're perfect for.