I like them all, but I like the first and third best... I would have to say the first one speaks to me the most... there's just a classic softness about it - you can almost smell the leather looking at it.
__________________
"Fashion can be bought. Style one must possess." ~ Edna Woolman Chase
i like the first one- and you girls do too. it looks like a speedy, haha. but the third one is really growing on me- the hardware makes it seem more special. and the last one is the perfect size- the duffel at top is a few inches longer and the second one is HUGE. the third one's shape is reminiscent of the stolen bag grr- a little more square and less long than the first. its on backorder, so i have some time to decide- i'd probably buy it after jan 25- my month from dec. to jan. is going to be a "save" month, haha. we'll see if that works with all the sales!
Im probably not going to be any help, because I love all three.. But, I think if you want a more special/unique bag I would go with two or three, they are both really nice and it just depends on how big you want your bag, if you can hold all your stuff you would need for a weekend in the smaller one, I would get that... but if you are like me, and over over over pack for a 2 day trip, I would get the larger one.
HTH!
__________________
"Deep down you may still be that same great guy I used to know. But it's not who you are underneath, it's what you do that defines you" Rachel Dawes, Batman Begins
the first one! the leather looks the nicest on it, plus it looks like something you found in a vintage shop somewhere. double plus the handle looks the nicest on it. i don't really like the metal hardware on the last one, it looks sorta painful to carry for more than five minutes.
__________________
"But I want you to remember, I intend this breast satirically." Susan from Coupling
i like the look of the first one the best, it's very classic. BUT, i have to say that my dad has a suede one very similar to the second one, and the way that the shape is and the way that the zipper goes around the whole top is extremely convenient for packing and using. because the zippered part sort of holds itself up and is structured, you can leave the mouth of the bag open and take stuff in and out--i know i'm not explaining it very well, but it really is a very useful shape.