I just got that belt in the mail, I love that belt. I wish it was that caramel color that 's pictured, but it is a lovely belt and it looks cute on you.
I bought a belt very similiar to this one about 4 years ago and I can't tell you how many times I have worn it. It was one of those things that got really trendy and then I would put it away. Then a year later I would pull it out again, thanking all my stars that I had kept it! I think that this will continue to happen to chunky belts, they will go way out and then come way back in! So keep it, it will be a good investment!
Side note: you totally remind me of this girl that I used to work with and miss since I left my old job 2 years ago and she moved to NY....funny! You both have similar styles! Which I love!