I'm not sure what you liked most about #2, but if it's the style, I bought this top last night at Target for $12.99. It's tighter on the model than the one I got for myself (mine wrinkles more at the bust like your #2). Also the detail at the neck is a sort of crochet with brown wooden beads.
Also comes in a rusty orange, brown and off-white. So, if what you liked most about #2 was the color...then I'm being no help at all!
I like the first one, but I feel like they're not special enough to drop that amount of $$. I'm sure you can find similar tops at stores like forever 21, rampage, etc.