I like them both! I would probably wear the first during the day and the second would be more for evening activities, so I guess it depends on when you're planning on wearing them. I think they could both work for day/night...that's just what I first thought of each when I saw them!
__________________
Fashion is art you live your life in. - Devil Wears Prada | formerly ttara123
Personally I'm not digging the button or piping on the first. I really like the second though. I like the toe shape better. It just looks sleeker to me.