STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

i am going to buy the j crew danielle flat sandal and am trying to decide which color.  they need to be versatile and go with almost everything.  i was originally looking for a flat strappy silver metallic sandal, so at first i wanted to get this color - it's a little darker than what i wanted but close enough i think.


hoerver, they don't have it at any jc stores in my area (in my size), so i'd have to order online (not a problem really though).  instead i tried these, which i also like and which the sa assures me are equally versatile:


it's sort of a matte/pale pink nude color.  they sort of looked nude on my feet and i didn't feel that pale, which i liked (i am seriously pale so this color in a top or dress might wash me out, but i liked the shoes).  these are at the b&m store waiting for me to purchase unless i go with the grey ones.  haven't seen the grey color irl but i can go to the only store that got them in - they don't have my size but i can look at the color.

to sum up, please tell me:

1)  which color is more versatile?
2) which color is more falttering on pale skin (that will hopefully get a bit darker this summer)? 

thanks!