hehehheeh, I know! I can't help myself. Shoes, sigh. I'm not buying them at the moment but I was curious because I've wanted them for a while and now they're only on eBay.
i have several pair of j.crew shoes. i'd say that for the most part they run true to size. i do have one pair of ankle strap pumps that i had to go down a full size (and they're still a little floppy) but i think that was just a freak thing with that style.
speaking of that pair... they are also not very comfortable. but, i have two pair of j.crew boots that i've had for 3+ years that are awesome comfortable and i had a pair of sandals many years ago that i wore to death (literally) that were incredibly comfortable.
their shoes are really well made or at least the pairs i have are.
I have several pairs of JCrew shoes. I love their boots and flip flops...both I find very confortable. In terms of shoes its been hit or miss either very comfortable not at all comfortable. I find the shoes to be all over the map in terms of size...I have tried on several of the spring shoes and many run a full size big including:
These run about half a size small:
I have this pair and they are very uncomfortable...but my foot is on the wide side...I think they are a little too narrow for me...otherwise they are true to size
I have this pair at home in two sizes...I'm a 7 1/2...I ordered a 7 and 8 because I had no idea on size...I think I am leaning toward the 8.
I have had a pair of jcrew kitten heel (similar to your 1st one) for many years. They're comfortable NOW.. but I remember it took me a long time to break them in. They are pretty stiff.
Lynnie, I wish I had a digital camera so I could post a picture but I don't. They shoes are very cute...soft leather, beautiful turquoise color and the fish detail is adorable. I don't have the prettiest feet but they look better on than other sandals I've tried. They seem to run true to size. I wish they did come in half sizes...I'm a 7 1/2....I feel like the 7 is a smidge to short and the 8 is a smide too long, but I think I will end up keeping the 8's. I might consider cutting the back strap off...simply because I prefer thongs to slings.