i LOVE the color. Why did you want to return it- did you want something else or do you have something similar? If you're not crazy about it, then return it- $77 could be put towards something else. I like it a lot though, but I'm a bad person to talk to about purses since I really don't like to buy them.
keep it! i have one very similar, except the leather is kind of pebbled...actually, it sounds like the one you're describing (more detail, square buckle) - maybe it's the same. if so, definitely keep it! i love it.
__________________
freedom's just another word for nothing left to lose - janis