I tried these on during the last Fields days and I was very pleasantly surprised with the fit of #4. I originally was going to get #1 but I fell in love with #4 and in the end I couldn't decide so I didn't get either... hehe.
The thing about #4 is you could totally work the SATC Charlotte vibe with it - it's got more of a classic shape. But number 1 has kickbutt colors and is more fun. Tough choice. Can you get both? :D
__________________
http://v247.tumblr.com One cannot perceive beauty, but with a serene mind -Thoreau