karina i voted for #1 because i personally love that style of pumas and pink and brown are the colors of my wedding! (the shoes aren't quite the same shades but you get my drift!)
I have the first ones. I think they are cute, and I get lots of compliments. But, they give NO support. I can't wear them if I am going to be on my feet for prolonged periods of time. If that's not an issue, get them--they are like slippers.
__________________
Know first, who you are; and then adorn yourself accordingly.
-Epictetus