I like the second sweater as well. If you dont decide on something else the scoopneck longsleeve tees are really cute. I think they are about fifty dollars.
wait- is the second sweater a sweater or a poncho? i thought it was a sweater with bell sleeves, but now that i look at it again, it looks like a poncho- which if it is, i veto my first vote and go with the 1st sweater.