I cant see the picture of the other color. If you are planning on using it for nights out, I think it's too big. I usually try to take the smallest possible/bag clutch that holds my nessecities.
I love the color. I guess it comes down to personal preference, and what youre using it for. If you dont mind having to hold the bag, and you would need something larger anyway, then it could be good. Hmm..I don't know, i'm still a little torn. I still think it's too big for going out, but that's just me.
I like it and think it would be versatile in the sense that you can wear it with blacks and/or browns (caramel color). For casual nights out, I think you could get away with it (especially in black).
I think that it could be versatile and work for night. Very cute! Love both colors. Not that this would sway your decision but i just read an article about oversized clutches being the next BIG thing... http://www.whowhatweardaily.com/website/full_article.php?id=512