#2 and #3 are my favorites. Personally, I'd get #2 because I love red bags. But, I think that #3 is a more practical choice since it would go with more things. They're both great, though!
You guys aren't making this easy! Here's another option I had been looking at:
I really want something that will go with "everything" like a neautral. I wear a lot of brown but have started to wear black a lot too. I also wear a lot of Navy, green, grey, & teal!
#3 will be a classic because of its style and color---and would go with pretty much everything. But #2 is a beautiful bag--and would definitely stand out (yet still be classic).
I like #1 and #2. I think you should get #2 though, it is so pretty and I have a bag similar in color and I can wear almost anything with it. It is very versatile!