i'm pretty fair on my face- i really like this cream blush by revlon- it looks really bright red in the case. I think the other colors mentioned may be pretty similar to what you already own. I'll find the name of the one i'm talking about, but it is very strong, you only need the smallest dab. But it will look like you've been out in the cold, and is great in the fall/winter. I think it will look stunning with green eyes.
ETA: it is revlon cream blush in first blush, you only need the tiniest dab
Right now I use Nars "orgasm", but I am kinda of getting tired of the color, any recs??? I am lightskinned, and have green eyes as you can see in my pic.
I use Nars orgasm, too! Except it is in a dual compact with a bronzer called Laguna. Before that, I used Clinique Transparency Bronze and Stila Bud. So maybe one of those?
I use Nars Orgasm too, but I also like Lorac cheek stain. You have to usew it under foundation, but it is very natural looking. Benefit makes one too, and I think Tarte has a gel version. I bought it at Sephora. It also makes a great lip stain.
I really like cream blushes. My favorite is Estee' Lauder BlushLights Creamy Cheek Color in Honey Shimmer. It is such a great color. I almost freaked out when I thought they were discontinuing it but it was a false alarm.