Okay, here are some photos of me wearing them. I'm 99% sure I'm going to keep the size 10, but I kind of want that extra push from your guys' opinions to make it 100%.
So, here is the size 10:
Size 12:
So, what do you think?? (I know there's not a HUGE difference, but there is a slight one in bagginess of the shorts)
I think both look great, so I say go for whichever are most comfortable. I LOVE the shorts. I've had them in my Gap "shopping cart" for a while and I think you've inspired me to buy them!
Cute... definitely the 10's. I would even say you could wear the 8's. Might be worth a try. If they have any stretch in them, my experience with my Gap cropped pants is that they stretch alot....