Do you have an eyeliner brush? I also had trouble with my smudgepot. I was using an angled stiff brush but I went to Sephora and asked them to show me how to apply it. They recommended the brush that Stila makes for it (of course).
I make sure the brush is clean, roll it into the waxy liner, hold my eyelid taught, then draw a line from inner eyelid out, sometimes going over it to make a cat eye. If you wanted a smudgey look, I would just draw a normal line around the perimeter and IMMEDIATELY smudge with a Q tip or this brush (which was my fave but I lost it!)
If you wait too long, the line will set. I find that the smudgepots stay on like ALL DAY even after the gym.
I also use an angled brush to apply mine. I line the upper lid and *lightly* line the lower lid (I do this right after lining the upper lid, without dipping the brush again so that the application is light and not racoon-y). Just remember a little goes a long way with this stuff! One day when I wasn't careful with the amount on the brush I ended up looking like Ellen in that commercial and had to start over. This stuff is amazing though, it stays put all day!
I like to use an angled brush, too, but I prefer Sephora's eyebrow brush because it's pretty thin and stiff.
I find that no matter how hard I try, I always get too much liner on my brush... I always keep tissue nearby to blot before I apply. I smudge immediately after I apply with a Q-tip.
Thanks! I have an angled brush and a thin eyeliner brush so I will play with both of them after work of course. For some reason I just thought I might need to wet the stuff before using it.