I was never a lipstick kinda gal, always preferring Chapstick or some sort of sheer lipgloss but after a 2 day search at several Sephora's I found my HG lipstick!
It is Benefit's Silky Finish Lipstick in Nice Knickers:
First off, its not really a lipstick, its more in between a gloss and a lipstick (similar texture to Clinique's Almost Lipstick but more pigmented). The color is perfect for me, as if you simply enhanced my natural color. There are no flavors or scents which I love bc I HATE that perfumey smell of lipstick.
Normally, I find Benefit to be all bells and whistles but no performance yet this has been an exception. Let me know if you've tried it.
I have also been impressed with this lipstick. The color I have is "Lady's Choice", and it is a really natural nude shade. The feel is very different from any other lipstick that I have used. I agree that it is really exceptional.
It means "Holy Grail", as in the ultimate thing that you have been on a quest for. It took me a while to understand what it stood for, too. They use this term a lot on Makeupalley.com, which is a great site for reviews of all kinds of make up and beauty items.