STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

cahabo · Kate Spade

Lost (2/18)

KaffeeKlatsch · Marc Jacobs

Could she have left him with someone else? The whole 'never ask me about what I did' thing was a bit twisted...she wouldn't have actually done something 'to' him, would she? As a way to spare him from ever having to go back to the island?

ILoveChoo · Hermes

I think Kate his him away somewhere to protect him from the Island. I'm pretty sure she didn't want him going back there. I hadn't thought about the Ben connection... I think she has a connection to someone Sawyer knew (remember he whispered something to her before he jumped off the plane? and she keeps making secret phone calls to someone that I think has something to do with him.) Anyway, I'm thinking she gave Aaron to them for safe keeping. But the Ben thing would explain why she was so distraught...

I lived "we're not going to guam, are we?"

I wonder if Jack's grandpa is going to be around again.

Elle · Hermes

I was thinking Kate gave Aaron to Claire's mom ...? For awhile there it seemed like Sun was going to bring Aaron to live with her little girl, but I don't think they would have had time for that.

I thought the flashes were supposed to have stopped when Locke righted the wheel thing - or did they get stuck in the time they were when he did that? I'm going to be annoyed if we have a bunch of episodes where the Losties are fighting off the old-school Dharma folks!

Metric · Gucci

Elle wrote:

I was thinking Kate gave Aaron to Claire's mom ...? For awhile there it seemed like Sun was going to bring Aaron to live with her little girl, but I don't think they would have had time for that.

I thought that as well. Ben was trying to trick Kate into thinking that Claire's mom was trying to take Aaron away to get Kate to agree to go back (Claire's mom doesn't know Aaron exsists and wasn't trying to take him).

Don't you love Daniel Faraday's mom?

Luv2Shop · Kate Spade

I thought she gave him to Claire's mom too until I saw ILoveChoo's post about the whole Sawyer thing. It reminded me, doesn't he have a daughter out there somewhere? With that woman who he conned but then later Kate met her and she helped her see her mom?

I was kind of annoyed about how they made SUCH a big deal about EVERYONE going back to the island and some of them fought it so hard (Kate, Sayid, Hurley) but there they all were on the plane when it was time to go. Seemed too easy after all that trouble. I want the explination as to why they all ended up being there SOON!

And seeing Jin in the Dharma coveralls was just too wierd. What the heck is going on there?

My husband seems to think Ben is going to keep his promise to Mr. Whidmore about killing his daughter for revenge for killing Alex. If Penny dies I will FREAK. I love her and Desmond!!!!!!

Vanessa · Kate Spade

My first guess was that the island would stop jumping when Locke left the island as Ben did, but then it doesn't make sense why everyone has to go back. However if we entertain that thought it could be the island was in the 70s when he left and the Losties are stuck in that time now and pretending to be Dharma employees.
I thought the show had a couple good lines like when Ben said "who cares" and also when Jack asked him how he could read and Ben replied "My mother taught me" (which is not true since his mom died at childbirth). Funny anyway.

I have really liked this season so far - seasons 3 & 4 were brutal for me.

sydney · Kate Spade

Metric wrote:

Elle wrote:

I was thinking Kate gave Aaron to Claire's mom ...? For awhile there it seemed like Sun was going to bring Aaron to live with her little girl, but I don't think they would have had time for that.

I thought that as well. Ben was trying to trick Kate into thinking that Claire's mom was trying to take Aaron away to get Kate to agree to go back (Claire's mom doesn't know Aaron exsists and wasn't trying to take him).

Don't you love Daniel Faraday's mom?

Metric - I agree with you - DF's mom is a great character and I thought the same thing about Claire's mom.

kenzie · Chanel

I think someone (Ben?) either took Aaron or Kate gave him to someone because she was told to. Since he technically wasn't born yet for the first crash, I don't think he was supposed to be on flight 316 back to "Gaum." I think someone came to Kate and told her Aaron shouldn't go, so either that someone took care of it or Kate did it herself.

Yes, Sawyer has a daughter named Clementine with the woman from "The Long Con" episode (I forget her name). I think it was from season one or two.

Here are the rest of my ideas (I've been meaning to post a blog about this, but haven't got around to it this week):

- I'm pretty sure the left behinders on the island have infiltrated the Dharma initiative, probably at Faraday's suggestion. I'm also pretty sure we'll see the full scene play out with Daniel and the Swan (from the season premiere) as well as the scene where Daniel tells young Charlotte never to come back to the island.

- The person who told Hurley to be on the plane was Charlie. I mean, Hurley's toting around a guitar case! Who else's would it be?

- I think Hurley is going to record the numbers on the radio signal. It seriously sounded like his voice when the Frenchies landed on the island and were listening to the signal.

I have more, but I can't remember them right now.

Oh, and best line of the show? "We're not going to Guam, are we?" Love it!

Luv2Shop · Kate Spade

kenzie wrote:

- I'm pretty sure the left behinders on the island have infiltrated the Dharma initiative, probably at Faraday's suggestion. I'm also pretty sure we'll see the full scene play out with Daniel and the Swan (from the season premiere) as well as the scene where Daniel tells young Charlotte never to come back to the island.

- The person who told Hurley to be on the plane was Charlie. I mean, Hurley's toting around a guitar case! Who else's would it be?

I do hope they show this scene because where Daniel and Charlotte have been in the past and why really confuses the crap out of me.

And the thing about Charlie, BRILLIANT!! I totally agree! (I miss Charlie)

blubirde · Chanel

What if Claire came back and she has Aaron? It's just a shot in the dark, of course, but we didn't ever see a body, right?

And it seems odd to me that Sun would leave her kid as well. Wouldn't she want Jin to meet her? Do they have a plan for getting home? Are they dumb for not asking questions or did they and we will only learn about it later?

(I just watched the episode tonight, in case you can't tell!)

kenzie · Chanel

blubirde wrote:

What if Claire came back and she has Aaron? It's just a shot in the dark, of course, but we didn't ever see a body, right?

I'm pretty sure Claire is dead, but I think you're onto something with Claire. I think it's highly likely that she's the one who came to Kate and told her what she had to do- maybe in a dream. Kate's seen Claire in her dreams before and Claire was very adament about Kate never bringing Aaron back to the island.

Boots · Gucci

One of the things I love about Lost is that the fans get to come up with all sorts of ideas and then the writers always find a a way to one up us with what really happened.

My theory is that Ben when to the boat dock to kill Penny ("tie up some loose ends" as he said) but accidentaly killed Desmond's son Charlie. Ben was very shaked when he was on the phone with Jack and Ben is never shaken unless he has lost control of a situation (like killing a child instead of Widmore's daughter like he wanted to.) I also think then the 2 Charlies (rock star Charlie and Desmond's son) came to Hurley and convinced him to return to the island (explains why Hurley had the guitar case and why he was so upset to see Ben on the plane.)

I also agree that Kate gave Aaron to Sawyer's baby mamma. She would want some one who she trusted (they pulled that scam in one of the flashbacks) and who had no connection to Ben to keep Aaron safe from the island for her. As far as we know, only Kate & Sawyer know about Sawyer's daughter.